11/14/2022 Minutes - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

AMENDED LANDMARKS COMMISSION CITY OF NORTH OLMSTED MINUTES OF NOVEMBER 14,2022 7:00 PM Mr.Morse called the meeting to order at 7:00 pm via online meeting. Present: Tom Dubowski, James Gearhart, Jim Morse, Elizabeth Kukwa, Duane Limpert, Sarah Egan-Reeves, Gretchen Schuler Absent:David Neville,David Anderson Staff: City Planner Nahid Parsipour,Law Assistance Bryan O'Malley Mr. Dubowski moved, seconded by Ms. Egan-Reeves, to excuse the absences of Mr. Neville and Mr.Anderson.Motion passed 7-0. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Landmarks Commission minutes of September 19, 2022 was submitted for approval at the meeting. Mr.Dubowski had some corrections I the minutes of September 19 meeting: Under the first page under the Robert C Nagy,Discussion,up in a copier, says "installing the solar panel",while it should be"panels".then down in the bold type,this is a showing the"solar panel"so that should be changed to "solar panels".And then right after that says"or"that should be"on". Ms. Schuler moved,and Mr. Dubowski seconded,to approve the September 19 Landmarks Commission minutes,as amended by Mr.Dubowski.The motion was approved 7-0. NEW BUSINESS 22-23184; Nancy Clark; 26885 Butternut Ridge Road This application did not have a Representative. Mr. O'Malley indicated that the commission can proceed with the application besides the applicant's absence. If it can be proved that the applicant's participation is required by the Commission,the case can be tabled. To begin,Ms.Parsipour explained that the proposal included building a new garage in a different position that is visible from the street. The previous garage will be demolished. The property is located at 26885 Butternut Ridge Road, and that is located at A-one family residence district. The new garage complies with the setback ordinance and accessory uses ordinance in this zone. The historic design guidelines advise against using aluminum and vinyl siding on top of already-used historic materials,however,in this case,the major building's exterior walls are vinyl and aluminum and accessory structures, including garages, are subordinate in size and detail to it. Ms. Shuler asked about the old garage material. Ms. Parsipour answered that there was nor any information in this regard.Mr.Dubowski mentioned that changing the location of the garage,visible from the street is questionable. Ms. Eager-Reeves asked if the application could be tabled till the commission can get clarification from the applicant and someone give Nancy a bulleted list of the questions that the commission members had. Mr. Morse mentioned the questions as following: why the applicant wants to destroy the old garage and why the placement of the new garage would be different.