Laserfiche WebLink
512T22, 8'.36 AM Consultant Selection <br />Short List Rating <br />Prime Consultant Selected on 1110612020 <br />District: 12 County: VAR Route: D12 Section: Bridge Rehabilitations 2021-2 <br />Agreement: 35400 <br />Project Type: Design PID'. 105909 <br />DBE Contract Participation Goal: 15.0% <br />DBE Contract Development Goal'. None <br />EDGE Contract Participation Goal: None <br />EDGE Contract Development Goal'. None <br />7 EXHIBIT <br />G <br />y <br />SBE Set Aside: None <br />Project Description. <br />13ndgc rcpatrs an 8 etrucnacs in Cayahogo County_ f neirOnmcnual 1.cutncnlctiuu will be c0111plcmd by the District Specific <br />;tuehr cs l"wd in scupcaf xerviccs <br />Category Management 8 Team <br />past <br />Pro' <br />I <br />Total <br />�I <br />DBE <br />S <br />.Prof Mgr Staff Workload <br />Perform. <br />A r <br />pp oath <br />Met <br />Total Value 10 <br />F 2255 1F00 <br />25 <br />100 <br />THE OSBORN ENGINEERING 10 <br />COMPANY <br />'�1 I 10 <br />X30 <br />I 30— <br />24 <br />g8 <br />WALLACE 8 PANCHER, INC 10 <br />I 0 <br />25 <br />g0 <br />F— <br />E L ROBINSON ENGINEERING OF 9 <br />OHIO CO <br />2s F— <br />30 <br />25 <br />89 <br />OHM ADVISORS 9 <br />�� <br />29 <br />25 <br />87 <br />FISHBECK, THOMPSON,CARR & <br />1 9 <br />is <br />30 <br />23 <br />e6 <br />HUeER, R, INC.INC <br />I� <br />COMPASS INFRASTRUCTURE GROUP <br />LLC <br />9 <br />79 <br />28 <br />24 <br />85 <br />Comments to Supplement the Numerical Scores <br />(Sub -Consultant Information shown for Reference) <br />THE OSBORN ENGINEERING COMPANY 85% <br />BARR ENGINEERING INCORPORATED 15% <br />Project Manager: Shelley Kiwala <br />Project Manager'. The consultant project manager has been practicing engineering and design for 22 years and worked <br />within the consultant's transportation group since the beginning of her career. <br />Staff The consultant presented a strong staff that possess knowledge and experience in all technical project areas. but <br />with slightly less overall experience than other competing firms. <br />Past Performance. The consultant has an above average CES rating based on two design projects rated within the past <br />three years. <br />Project Approach: Excellent project approach that addressed all key technical areas of the project scope. Good mention <br />of safety study. Technical discussion and project details were less specific compared to other submitting firms. <br />WALLACE & PANCHER, INC. 54% <br />COMPASS INFRASTRUCTURE GROUP, LLC 15% <br />E. L. ROBINSON ENGINEERING OF OHIO CO. 15% <br />IBI GROUP ENGINEERING SERVICES (USA) INC. 15% <br />SURVEYING AND MAPPING. LLC 1% <br />Project Manager. Patrick Schwan, P.E. <br />Project Manager: The project manager has 25 years of transportation experience. He has been responsible for the <br />development and design of various projects including roadway planning, <br />noesosspum,d,A ateonusdtsscesl,rbktindecrut m 1-s <br />