2022-070 Resolution - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

6129122, 8 3 AM Consultant Selection Short List Selection Prime Consultant Selected on 11/0612020 District: 12 County: VAR Route: D12 Section: Bridge Rehabilitations 2021.2 Agreement 35400 Project Type: Design PID: 105909 DBE Contract Participation Goal: 15.0% DBE Contract Development Goal'. None SBE Set Aside: None EDGE Contract Participation Goal: None EDGE Contract Development Goal: None Project Description: Bridge repwn on N snucmres in Cuyahoga County. En, .,i ducuntcnwtian will be completed by the DCama Specific suuaurcv Iwrd in swpc of........ Consultants on the Short List COMPASS INFRASTRUCTURE GROUP, LLC E. L. ROBINSON ENGINEERING OF OHIO CO. FISHBECK, THOMPSON, CARR & HUBER, INC. OHM ADVISORS THE OSBORN ENGINEERING COMPANY WALLACE & PANCHER, INC. Consultants Eliminated without Ratings ALFRED BENESCH & COMPANY 65% BG ENGINEERING GROUP LLC 25% SURVEYING AND MAPPING, LLC 10% Project Manager: Dean Morrison, PE Technical errors in the ramp bridge location and utility discussion. LJB INC 85% BARR ENGINEERING INCORPORATED 3% BG ENGINEERING GROUP LLC 12% Project Manager: Dan Springer, PE, PMP The consultant's discussion lacked location specific details and was light on the overall project management approach. .............................................................««,,,»,,.,»»..............,,.»..»,...,..,..,.„ PALMER ENGINEERING CO. 85% BARR ENGINEERING INCORPORATED 15% Project Manager'. Matthew Johnson, PE Did not discuss their approach in regards to a two part project scope Patrick Engineering Inc. 85% 2LMN, INC. 5% BARR ENGINEERING INCORPORATED 1% BG ENGINEERING GROUP LLC 9% Project Manager: Naureen Dar The consultant did not discuss environmental work or specific stakeholder coordination. MOT discussion was light compared to other competing firms. RETTEW ASSOCIATES, INC. 70% ratparmssppuuc.dot.state.on.pauesspe:rppm,amae,.mm 1;2